The Role of Foreign Banks in Post-Crisis Asia: The Importance of Method of Entry
Montgomery, Heather | January 2003
First, using data on the presence of foreign banks via branching as well as subsidiaries, the study shows that the presence of foreign banks in the four crisis-hit countries is actually much larger than has been previously reported once the presence of foreign branches is accounted for in the data. However, the percentage of assets controlled by foreign banks in Asia is still lower than that of other emerging economies, despite great increases in the post-crisis period. The author reviews regulations on foreign bank entry that may have limited the presence of foreign banks or influenced the method of entry (branching versus subsidiary). Given recent regulatory changes and the need for bank recapitalization in the region, the presence of foreign banks is expected to increase in the near future, so this study next takes up the policy implications of this trend. To date, foreign banks in most Asian countries appear to perform relatively worse than their domestic counterparts as measured by return on equity, cost to income ratios, and the ratio of problem loans to total loans. This finding contradicts previous research in other emerging economies, and may be due to the fact that foreign bank entry in Asia is still a very recent phenomenon, and has occurred mostly through the takeover of troubled banks in the region. The second policy issue examined here is the stability of lending by foreign banks relative to domestic banks. Macroeconomic data suggests that foreign bank lending may in some cases be more stable than domestic bank lending, particularly during crisis, but that the stability of foreign bank lending varies greatly by method of entry. Cross border claims of foreign banks are the most volatile, followed by foreign bank branch lending. Lending by foreign bank subsidiaries capitalized in the host country appear to be more stable than domestic lending, perhaps providing much needed capital during times of crisis. Therefore, foreign banks play an important role in Asia, not only in the traditional ways by providing new services and stimulating competition and efficiency, but also by contributing to stability of the banking sector in the face of macroeconomic fluctuations. However, the mode of foreign entry seems to have important implications for the contributions of foreign banks. Since lending by off-shore banks and foreign bank branches seems to be more volatile than locally capitalized foreign subsidiaries, policy makers in Asia should encourage foreign players to enter via fully-owned subsidiaries or joint ventures and move away from the previous pattern of branch-based entry.
CitationMontgomery, Heather. 2003. The Role of Foreign Banks in Post-Crisis Asia: The Importance of Method of Entry. © Asian Development Bank Institute. http://hdl.handle.net/11540/4156. License: CC BY 3.0 IGO.
Urban Development Finance
Small Business Finance
Roundtable on International Trade and Finance
Regional Development Finance
Public Service Finance
Non-Bank Financial Institutions
Local Government Finance
Local Currency Financing
Limited Resource Financing
International Financial Institutions
Government Financial Institutions
Financing of Infrastructure
Financial Sector Development
Public Sector Infrastructure
Public Sector Management
Public Sector Projects
International Monetary Relations
International Financial Market
Economics of Education
State of taxation
Tax revenue estimating
Tax administration and procedure
Real property and taxation
Effect of taxation on land use
Effect of taxation on labor supply
Intergovernmental tax relations
Inheritance and transfer tax
Investment of public funds
Intergovernmental fiscal relations
Government lendingShow allCollapse
MetadataShow full item record
Users also downloaded
Knowledge Solutions: TOOLS, METHODS, AND APPROACHES TO DRIVE DEVELOPMENT FORWARD AND ENHANCE ITS EFFECTS Serrat, Olivier (Asian Development Bank, 2010-12-01)A competency approach befits knowledge management and learning. Knowledge Solutions are handy, quick reference guides to tools, methods, and approaches that propel development forward and enhance its effects. They fit in five comprehensive areas: (i) strategy development, (ii) management techniques, (iii) collaboration mechanisms, (iv) knowledge sharing and learning, and (v) knowledge capture and ...A competency approach befits knowledge management and learning. Knowledge Solutions are handy, quick reference guides to tools, methods, and approaches that propel development forward and enhance its effects. They fit in five comprehensive areas: (i) ...
Duncan, Ron (Asian Development Bank, 2011-07-01)This collection of studies on the political economy of Pacific island countries was authored by writers from various disciplinary backgrounds. Their research confirms the results of political economy studies of economic reform in developing countries from elsewhere around the world and shines new light on the kinds of obstacles that have to be overcome for economic reform to be successful in the ...This collection of studies on the political economy of Pacific island countries was authored by writers from various disciplinary backgrounds. Their research confirms the results of political economy studies of economic reform in developing countries ...
Strengthening the Ombudsman Institution in Asia: Improving Accountability in Public Service Delivery through the Ombudsman Asian Development Bank (Asian Development Bank, 2011-06-01)Accountability is essential for good governance, and in many Asian countries the ombudsman is the key accountability institution. Originating in the West, the concept of the ombudsman arrived relatively late in Asia. Yet more and more ombudsman offices are being established in Asia, and they play a critical role in the fight against incompetence and injustice on the part of government officials. This ...Accountability is essential for good governance, and in many Asian countries the ombudsman is the key accountability institution. Originating in the West, the concept of the ombudsman arrived relatively late in Asia. Yet more and more ombudsman offices ...