Diverse Paths toward “the Right Institutions:”Law, the State, and Economic Reform in East Asia
Woo-Cumings, Meredith | April 2001
Abstract
IVABSTRACTIn the wake of the global financial crisis that began in 1997, an influential body of opinionarose which argued that a primary cause of the crisis in the affected countries was a lack ofinstitutional transparency and accountability, and more generally, an absence of the rule of law. Thisargument reflected a growing international consensus in the 1980s and 1990s that different lawtraditions had differential effects on economic development. More specifically, the argument was thata common law tradition was more likely to promote economic development because it was the bestsource of and predictor for the rule of law, transparency and accountability. By the same token, thecivil law tradition was more likely to privilege state intervention in economic processes, and to be lesssensitive to concerns about the rule of law and transparency.I argue that however compelling this argument may be—and I lay the argument out insome detail—legal traditions and institutions do not determine the nature of the state, or its likely rolein the economy, nor do they critically determine the course of economic development. Therefore, thecurrent tendency of pointing to the “rule of law” as an elixir which will fix various contemporaryproblems of development may simply be wrong. Instead of common law leading to a minimal stateand the broadest extension of the market, or civil law leading to state intervention in the economy andcorresponding shrinkage of market activity, there may be no relationship at all between forms of lawand the role of the state. The current discourse about the rule of law, as well as the long intellectualpedigree behind the argument about law and economic development, may misguide us into thinkingthat we have unlocked the conundrum of economic growth and reform, when in fact we may be lesswell off today than when we tried to understand the reasoning behind state-directed developmentprograms. This is because of the built-in bias in this literature against the state, which is viewed as ipsofacto inimical to economic development. And it is the common law background that is assumed to beipso facto conducive to development and to the virtues of transparency and accountability.In this paper I review the core literature on the rule of law and economic growth; theinfluential arguments of some institutional economists on the relationship between law, finance andgovernment; and the current consensus on the part of international development agencies, like theWorld Bank and the Asian Development Bank, on these issues. In particular I will examine theinfluential argument by Rafael La Porta, Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes, Andrei Shleifer and RobertVishny, on the superiority of the Anglo-American common law system (as versus the civil lawtradition of continental Europe, Latin America, and East Asia) in fostering financial development. Idemonstrate the inadequacy of these arguments on the rule of law and economic development, byflashing them against the backdrop of East Asia.
Citation
Woo-Cumings, Meredith. 2001. Diverse Paths toward “the Right Institutions:”Law, the State, and Economic Reform in East Asia. © Asian Development Bank Institute. http://hdl.handle.net/11540/4123. License: CC BY 3.0 IGO.Keywords
Financial Stability
Financial Management System
Financial Restructuring
Capital Market Development
Erosion
Market Development
Economics
Erosion
International Economics
International Financial Market
Multilateral Financial Institutions
Economic Recession
Market
Crisis
Business recessions
Multilateral development banks
Regulatory reform
Capital
Show allCollapse
Citable URI
http://hdl.handle.net/11540/4123Metadata
Show full item recordUsers also downloaded
-
Annual Report 2014: Organizational Information
Asian Development Bank (Asian Development Bank, 2015-01-01)The page has additional information for the ADB Annual Report 2014. In 2014, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) approved $22.93 billion in development assistance, including $13.69 billion financed by ADB’s ordinary capital resources and special funds, and a record $9.24 billion by cofinancing partners. Disbursements totaled $10.01 billion, an increase of $1.47 billion (17%) from 2013, and the ...The page has additional information for the ADB Annual Report 2014. In 2014, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) approved $22.93 billion in development assistance, including $13.69 billion financed by ADB’s ordinary capital resources and special ... -
Annual Report 2014: Operational Data
Asian Development Bank (Asian Development Bank, 2015-01-01)The page has additional information for the ADB Annual Report 2014. In 2014, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) approved $22.93 billion in development assistance, including $13.69 billion financed by ADB’s ordinary capital resources and special funds, and a record $9.24 billion by cofinancing partners. Disbursements totaled $10.01 billion, an increase of $1.47 billion (17%) from 2013, and the first ...The page has additional information for the ADB Annual Report 2014. In 2014, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) approved $22.93 billion in development assistance, including $13.69 billion financed by ADB’s ordinary capital resources and special funds, ... -
ADB Perceptions Survey: Multinational Survey of Stakeholders 2012
Asian Development Bank (Asian Development Bank, 2013-08-01)The 2012 ADB Perceptions Survey gauges and tracks stakeholders’ perceptions of the mission of the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to help reduce poverty and contribute to development in Asia and the Pacific. The survey, the third of its kind since 2006, was carried out among 900 opinion leaders in 31 member countries, drawn from a broad cross section of stakeholders in government, media, civil society, ...The 2012 ADB Perceptions Survey gauges and tracks stakeholders’ perceptions of the mission of the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to help reduce poverty and contribute to development in Asia and the Pacific. The survey, the third of its kind since 2006, ...