Thailand’s Perennial Kra Canal Project: Pros, Cons and Potential Game Changers
Storey, Ian | September 2019
Abstract
Few mega construction projects have been on the drawing board for as long as Thailand’s Kra canal. The idea of cutting a waterway across the Isthmus of Kra in the Upper South of the country that would link the Gulf of Thailand with the Andaman Sea—and hence the Pacific and Indian Oceans—was first proposed more than 300 years ago. Since then the project has been repeatedly revived, resulting in a series of expensive engineering surveys and feasibility studies, before being quietly dropped.
The arguments for and against a Kra canal are longstanding and well-rehearsed.
Proponents of the canal point to the economic and strategic benefits that Thailand would accrue. They argue that the construction of the 100-kilometre canal, and related industrial infrastructure such as ports, manufacturing plants and oil refineries, would create jobs for tens of thousands of Thai workers, stimulate the economy (especially during periods of economic downturn) and, over the long-term, generate a lucrative revenue stream from the collection of shipping tolls. Militarily, the canal would enable the Thai navy to move ships quickly from one coast to the other during times of crisis. In addition, a Kra canal would also provide a faster and thus cheaper route between the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea, thus providing a viable alternative to the increasingly congested and “pirate infested” Straits of Malacca.
Detractors of the canal remain unconvinced. Their main argument is that a Kra canal is commercially unviable: that the massive construction costs could not be clawed back from toll fees as shipping companies would be reluctant to bear additional costs just to save two or three days sailing time (especially at a time when the price of oil is low)—a situation quite unlike the Suez and Panama Canals which save vessels weeks of extra time at sea. With regard to the strategic benefits, critics argue that Thailand faces no threats from its neighbours, a canal would cleave the country into two halves and thus embolden separatists in the Far South, and the ownership and operation of the waterway would inevitably become entangled in Great Power rivalry.
Citation
Storey, Ian. 2019. Thailand’s Perennial Kra Canal Project: Pros, Cons and Potential Game Changers. © ISEAS Yusof Ishak Institute. http://hdl.handle.net/11540/11321.ISSN
2335-6677
Keywords
Bus Transportation Costs
Demand For Transport
Means Of Transport
National Transport
Passenger Transport
Railways
Road & Highway Transport
Road Transportation Systems
Sea Transport
Transport Costs
Transport Efficiency
Transport Infrastructure
Transport Planning
Transport Policy
Transport Services
Transport Systems
Transport Tax
Transportation
Aid And Development
Asian Development Bank
Comprehensive Development Framework
Development Cooperation
Development Management
Development Planning
Development Strategies
Development In East Asia
Development Planning
Development Research
Green revolution
Modes of transport
Airports
Ports
Shipping
Taxis
Vehicle
Automobile industry
Road traffic
Railways
Inland transport
International transport
Public transport
Urban transport
Transport projects
Transport workers
Transport statistics
Transport networks
Urban traffic
Rural planning
Aid coordination
Industrial projects
Infrastructure projects
Natural resources policy
Educational development
Development strategy
Development models
Economic development
Communication and traffic
Navigation
Transport planes
Air transportation industry
Air transportation system
Intra-airport transportation
Inland water transportation
Intercoastal shipping
Marine transportation
Local transit
Highway transportation
Motor transportation
Student transportation
Choice of transportation
Public transportation
Transportation industry
Mass transit
Municipal transit
Communication in rural development
Communication in community development
Economic development projects
Development banks
Economic forecasting
Environmental auditing
Cumulative effects assessment
Human rights and globalization
Railroads
High-speed rail
Canals
Show allCollapse
Citable URI
http://hdl.handle.net/11540/11321Metadata
Show full item recordRelated items
-
The Impacts of the Thailand-Australia Free Trade Agreement and Thailand- New Zealand Closer Economic Partnership on Thai Dairy Import Prices, Journal of GMS Development Studies, Vol. 6, pp. 37–53
Suriya, Patcharee; Gan, Christopher; Hu, Baiding; Cohen, David A. (Asian Development Bank, 2014-10-01)This study investigates the impacts of the Thailand–Australia Free Trade Agreement and Thailand–New Zealand Closer Economic Partnership on Thailand’s dairy import prices. The study employs an import price model to examine the effects of a reduction in Thai tariffs for Australian and New Zealand dairy products on their prices. Empirical results show that the effects of a reduction in tariffs for ...This study investigates the impacts of the Thailand–Australia Free Trade Agreement and Thailand–New Zealand Closer Economic Partnership on Thailand’s dairy import prices. The study employs an import price model to examine the effects of a reduction in ... -
Thailand’s triple threat
Farrelly, Nicholas (Lowy Institute For International Policy, 2017-07-30)The economic malaise into which Thailand has fallen over the past decade also complicates any long-term security planning. Political instability has discouraged major new foreign investment, while a weak education system has condemned Thailand to being “trapped” as a middle-income economy.20 Over coming decades, Thailand will grapple with the need to manage an increasingly elderly and economically ...The economic malaise into which Thailand has fallen over the past decade also complicates any long-term security planning. Political instability has discouraged major new foreign investment, while a weak education system has condemned Thailand to being ... -
Managing Thailand’s Ageing Population
Sasiwongsaroj, Kwanchit; Burasit, Youngyut (ISEAS Yusof Ishak Institute, 2019-04-23)According to official figures, Thailand has been an ageing society since 2005. Estimates indicate that the percentage of people aged 65 and over in Thailand has increased from 5.0 per cent in 1950 to 8.4 per cent in 2000 and will continue to increase to 27.1 percent by 2050. These estimates mean that Thailand will become “a super-aged society” in the next 30 years. The percentage of the Thai population ...According to official figures, Thailand has been an ageing society since 2005. Estimates indicate that the percentage of people aged 65 and over in Thailand has increased from 5.0 per cent in 1950 to 8.4 per cent in 2000 and will continue to increase ...